BANKTHINK

Meredith Whitney on How to Bring Investors Back to Bank Stocks

Print
Email
Reprints
Comment (1)
Twitter
LinkedIn
Facebook
Google+

This year presents a great opportunity for bank CEOs. With most of the large macro issues behind them, companies and their leaders have a chance to differentiate themselves.

For large banks, that means demonstrating tangible return improvements from cost containment, effectively by getting smaller. For smaller banks that means demonstrating tangible return improvements from gaining scalable efficiencies, effectively by getting larger. What works for large banks will not work for small banks and vice versa.

For the past few years, the large banks, most of which are deemed systemically important financial institutions, have been all but banished from a practice they once dominated: acquisitions. "Too Big To Fail" has essentially meant that they have to operate "as is," shrink, and not even dare think about buying other banks. This has thrown a strange twist into M&A, as the "natural" buyers of banks are all but sidelined, leaving the smaller banks to take a leadership role in the market.

As uncomfortable as this situation may be for the larger institutions, it actually provides them an excellent opportunity: get better at executing with what they already have rather than getting bigger for the sake of getting bigger.

For many, this will be a near-term challenge. Not only have the big banks not been accustomed to going in reverse, only a handful of them are openly accepting that the current weak revenue environment may actually be here to stay.

Along those lines, a handful of banks have just begun to outline specific efficiency targets and put programs in place to drive profitability improvements. For others, plans are well underway and 2013 is poised to be a banner year. From investors' perspective, this will be a "show me" year for large bank CEOs.

This will also be the year for the smaller banks to step up to the M&A plate. Prices in excess of two times book value are going to be very few and far between, so prospective sellers should think about the quality of the partner in addition to the price tag. The reality that bank deals over the past three years were done at roughly half the multiple of deals prior to the crisis is unlikely to change given the Fed's commitment to a zero interest rate policy.

The fact that more and more deals are being done with both a stock and equity component should be viewed as good for sellers. They can both monetize their ownership in often illiquid investments and retain a carried interest in what I believe will be an enormous growth market for the newly created superregional banks of the next decade.

For nearly 20 years, the larger banks have outmuscled smaller banks in M&A and undercut them on price in loan originations. In the worst cases, during the mid-1990s, some smaller banks binged on commercial real estate loans and are only now beginning to recover from the hangover of credit losses. In the best cases, some smaller banks have focused internally on efficiencies and built dry powder and strong capital stockpiles.

One of the messages frequently lost on investors as well as operators of banks is that just as the regulators want the "Too Big to Fail" banks to shrink, they need the smaller banks to get larger. That is the only way to rebalance an industry that's been imbalanced for 15 years. It would be a gift to both large and small banks.

The reality is that although bank stocks had a great year in 2012, the KBW Bank Index is still more than 50% below its 2007 peak. Investors still underweight the sector. For the most part, they are tired of hearing more about legacy issues than plans to drive business-as-usual profitability.

That can change quickly if banks take a leadership role. Instead of being preoccupied with things that aren't working, focus intently on what is working. Legacy issues will persist – but so, too, will the need to adjust to the new operating environment and drive greater profitability. First quarter results are a great launching pad for a powerful 2013.

Meredith Whitney is the CEO of Meredith Whitney Advisory Group LLC.

 

JOIN THE DISCUSSION

(1) Comment

SEE MORE IN

RELATED TAGS

From Zero to Billions in Five Years: Banking's Busiest Builders

Several banks have been aggressively adding assets since the financial crisis. SNL Financial's list of publicly traded banks with the greatest asset growth since mid-2009 includes many investment vehicles formed after the downturn to buy banks. Several of those banks have gone public this year.

(Image: Fotolia)

Comments (1)
Some banks should restructure their business into a much less risky operation so as to be able to attract shareholders that appreciate much less risk, like widows and orphans, pension funds and insurance companies.


That could be done by banks, by for instance voluntarily agree to hold 15 percent in capital against all of their assets, with no risk differentiation that distorts.


And governments should be very appreciative of such an evolution and give special long term tax exemptions to any new capital raised for the super-safe banks.


If $500bn of fresh bank capital was raised, with a 15 percent capital against assets, that would leave room for $3 trillion of new bank credit.


And we, "the real economy", would certainly very much welcome the managers and the shareholders of the banks taking a smaller bite out of us.


http://subprimeregulations.blogspot.com/
Posted by Per Kurowski | Wednesday, January 30 2013 at 5:11PM ET
Add Your Comments:
Not Registered?
You must be registered to post a comment. Click here to register.
Already registered? Log in here
Please note you must now log in with your email address and password.

  LinkedIn

Women in Banking — American Banker: American Banker invites women executives across the banking and financial services industry to connect with one another, share news and best practices, and keep up with our Mentor Factor and Most Powerful Women in Banking initiatives.

Join our mailing list »

Our weekly eNewsletter contains timely and relevant news about women in banking across the web. Sign up for this must-read digest today.

Already a subscriber? Log in here
Please note you must now log in with your email address and password.