= Subscriber content; or subscribe now to access all American Banker content.

Wal-Mart Claims Issuers Block Progress of EMV Cards in U.S.

US Banker  |  May, 2010

Wal-Mart Stores Inc. said it is eager to deploy chip-and-PIN card technology as a stronger barrier against point-of-sale card fraud but that card issuers are balking.

Most U.S. issuers are loath to disrupt the existing model because, according to Wal-Mart, if the EMV Integrated Circuit Card Specifications were to become commonplace in this country, they would lose significant revenue on signature-based credit and debit card interchange fees.

"Issuers and networks are married to signature interchange, and as long as that continues … [it is] hindering U.S. adoption of chip-and-PIN technology," Jamie Henry, Wal-Mart's director of payment services, said last week at the Smart Card Alliance's annual meeting, in Scottsdale, Ariz. Henry suggested that a government-forced reduction in interchange rates might be the catalyst needed to push U.S. issuers and merchants to broad adoption of the EMV standard that is already common in other countries.

A longstanding industry debate over interchange erupted again this month as the Senate approved an amendment to the financial reform bill that would regulate debit interchange rates. PIN-based transactions generally cost merchants less than signature-based transactions.

"Lower interchange would push the industry toward chip-and-PIN," Henry said. "We would see more financial institutions become interested in controlling fraud. It would be more difficult to pass [fraud] costs on to merchants."

Only one financial institution in this country has agreed so far to issue EMV cards to U.S. residents: United Nations Federal Credit Union, which announced its plans this month to put a chip in its platinum Visa Inc. card. Visa said that though it can support any bank or credit union that plans to issue chip-and-PIN cards, it does not expect EMV issuance to become an immediate trend in the U.S.

Henry said Wal-Mart is a "strong advocate" of chip-and-PIN technology globally. POS fraud rates plummeted in markets that have adopted the EMV technology, he noted. "As far as we're concerned, signature [transactions] are a waste of time. Transactions need to be PIN or nothing," he said.

All of Wal-Mart's U.S. payment terminals are able to accept chip-and-PIN transactions, Henry said. But because major U.S. card issuers do not yet support EMV transactions, he said, Wal-Mart has no incentive yet to develop the software and other payment-processing technologies the transactions require.

Richard Mader, the executive director of the National Retail Federation's Association for Retail Technology Standards, said during the same panel discussion that, because their resources are spread so thinly, retailers are waiting for "clearer direction" from card issuers and networks before making any big investment in chip-and-PIN EMV technology.

"As long as there is uncertainty from issuers about chip-and-PIN, retailers will hesitate," Mader said.

Avivah Litan, a vice president and distinguished analyst at the Stamford, Conn., market research company Gartner Inc., said that, despite the security benefit to Wal-Mart from switching to chip-and-PIN, "security's not driving them — lower costs are driving them."

Wal-Mart's talk of the security benefits of contactless cards focuses too much on the point of sale, Litan said.

In this episode of Breaking Banks: American Banker's Innovator of the Year, John Hope Bryant of Operation Hope; Richard Brown and Charley Cooper of the blockchain consortium R3; and Ravi Srinivasan, who describes India's drastic move to stamp out cash.