Best Performing Bank Stocks of 2011
The year in bank stocks got off to a rough start. It turned worse still in the second half amid high volatility and repeated rallies inspired by euro zone rescue attempts that failed to sustain investor confidence.
- Libya spillover - Turmoil in Libya appeared to trigger the KBW Bank Index's first one-day decline of more than 3% in 2011.
- Bad economic news - A cluster of negative reports catalyzed worries about the faltering recovery, and the KBW Bank Index notched its first one-day loss of more than 4%.
- Debt-ceiling deadline - After weeks of gut-wrenching partisan brinksmanship, President Obama signed the Budget Control Act of 2011.
- Ratings cut - The KBW Bank Index plummeted 11% in the first trading day after S&P cut its rating of the U.S.
- Currency swap expansion - The Fed joined with other central banks to expand currency swap arrangements, driving the KBW Bank Index to a 7% one-day jump.
In a turbulent market, Commerce Bancshares was rewarded for its quiet stability. "They don't chase the latest fads and they don't run out to hot markets," an analyst told American Banker in July.
- 40% jump in EPS - The company reported that EPS increased 40% from the year prior in the first quarter as credit losses fell.
- Earnings miss - The company's shares tumbled on an earnings report that fell shy of analyst forecasts, reflecting pressure on the company's net interest margin and a contraction in its loan portfolio.
U.S. Bancorp cemented its reputation as one of the nation's most consistent and best performing large banks by expanding its loan portfolio and resisting net interest margin pressure.
- Earnings beat on revenue growth - In an industry struggling with anemic loan demand, U.S. Bancorp's 4% year-over-year growth in second quarter revenue stood out.
- Another beat - Another quarter, another earnings report that exceeded analyst forecasts.
Investors were pleased that Capital One's chargeoff rates fell below pre-recession levels. They appeared to give their assent as the company announced a pair of transformative deals.
- First quarter results - In its earnings report, Capital One said that its credit card chargeoff rate hit the lowest level in more than two years.
- ING deal - Capital One announced a deal to acquire ING Group NV's U.S. online banking business.
- HSBC deal - Capital One announced deal to acquire HSBC's domestic credit card business, and bucked sharp drop in KBW Bank Index the same day.
BB&T raised its loan growth forecast after the third quarter and announced another significant bank acquisition.
- Strong earnings - BB&T's shares outran the KBW Bank Index by 3 percentage points on the day of its first quarter earnings report, and the company declared its intent to be "aggressive" in looking for deals.
- BankAtlantic deal - BB&T agreed to acquire most of the ailing Florida operation for a 9% deposit premium, leaving bad assets with the seller.
PNC announced three acquisitions in 2011, and investors appeared to cheer the deals. Combined, the targets' assets are equal to about 10% of PNC's January 1 total.
People's United capped a string of purchases with a cash-and-stock deal for Danvers Bancorp early this year, and then refocused on consolidating its acquisitions and organic growth. The company underperformed the KBW Bank Index at first, but overtook its peers in the second half with the help of a large share repurchase program.
It was a bad year for bank stocks, but some bucked the trend. Here are the top six performers in the KBW Bank Index.
PhotosBest of BankThink 2015: Readers' Choice
PhotosBest of BankThink 2015: Editors' Choice
Photos'Tech Can Reinvent Banking or Dispose of It': Comments of the Week
Photos'Facebook Should Roll Up the Banking Sector': Comments of the Week
PhotosIs BSA Becoming a 'Bank Surveillance Act'?: Comments of the Week
PhotosAre the Big Banks Open for Small Business Lending?
Photos'Capital Has Consequences': Comments of the Week
Photos'Might as Well Start Paying the Fines Now': Comments of the Week