Community bank small-business loans are undercounted: FDIC survey

WASHINGTON — Small banks are lending to small businesses much more than previously thought, according to a preview released Wednesday of an upcoming Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. survey.

After surveying more than 1,000 banks with less than $10 billion in assets and conducting one-and-one follow-up discussions with 51 institutions, the FDIC concluded that small-business lending by those institutions was actually undercounted by at least $38 billion in the fourth quarter of 2015.

"Relying on call report proxy understates small business lending by small banks," the agency said in a synopsis of its first-ever small-business lending survey. The agency plans to release the full report on the survey sometime next year.

AB-110117-FDIC

Commercial and industrial loans of less than $1 million are typically a good proxy for calculating small-business loans made by small banks. In the fourth quarter of 2015, those C&I loans totaled $118 billion for banks with less than $10 billion in assets.

But after conducting the survey in 2016 and 2017 with the help of the Census Bureau, the FDIC found that many loans secured by one- to four-family residential properties and made by small banks are also often utilized by small businesses, which added roughly $16 billion to the total.

The FDIC data suggests small-business loan totals should be revised also because small banks said they often make loans above the normal threshold of $1 million to businesses with less than $1 million in annual revenue, which many would consider a small business. In fact, banks with assets of $1 billion to $10 billion said 20% of all their C&I loans that were greater than $1 million were to small businesses.

Using that estimate, the FDIC found that banks with $1 billion to $10 billion in assets made $21 billion in loans of more than $1 million to small businesses in the fourth quarter of 2015.

Banks with assets of less than $1 billion were not able to break out the same figures for the larger C&I loans made to small businesses. However, 86% of banks with less than $250 million in assets said that largely all of their C&I loans were made to small businesses, and 77% of banks between $250 million and $1 billion said that largely all of their C&I loans were made to small businesses.

Rather than relying on those figures, however, the FDIC used a more conservative approach by assuming that half of all C&I loans of more than $1 million made by banks with assets below $1 billion were made to small businesses in the fourth quarter of 2015. That approach added $93 million to the estimated total.

The FDIC also surveyed both small banks and large banks, and both said their top competitor is often a bank with assets of $1 billion to $10 billion.

Large banks said a bank in the $1 billion to $10 billion range in assets is a top competitor for small-business loans 74% of the time. Sixty-seven percent of large banks also said banks between $1 billion and $10 billion have a competitive advantage because they are able to offer more flexible loan terms, and 41% said those same banks can offer a more competitive interest rate.

The survey also found that small banks often think that small banks have a competitive advantage when it comes to personal attention and how quickly a decision is made on a loan.

Forty-three percent of large banks said that they have a competitive advantage in offering personal attention when making a loan. Small banks, on the other hand, said they have an even greater advantage. Fifty-eight percent of smaller institutions said they have the upper hand in providing personal attention, and 49% said they have an advantage in the speed of loan decisions.

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Small business lending Policymaking Community banking FDIC
MORE FROM AMERICAN BANKER