Shares of Commerce Bancorp spotlighted the fickleness of the stock market on Wednesday by failing to ignite despite a glowing evaluation by a major investment firm.

The stock, after being touted by A.G. Edwards & Sons, was caught in a wave of bank stock selling as investors booked profits from the prior day's run-up. Shares dropped $1.625, to $57.6875.

With a stellar second-quarter performance, Commerce Bancorp "continues to astound even us, one of the company's most ardent supporters," said David C. Stumpf, a banking analyst at A.G. Edwards.

Year over year, revenue at the Cherry Hill, N.J., banking company jumped 25% on 21% deposit growth and a 22% increase in loans.

Mr. Stumpf credited the company's marketing culture, saying shares can sustain valuations that "have more in common with growing retailers" than more subdued banks.

Commerce Bancorp's "unique strategy and execution skill will continue to produce impressive results," Mr. Stumpf said.

The company's "historically strong growth rate could actually accelerate" because of customer dissatisfaction from mergers, including First Union's takeover of the Northeast regional CoreStates Financial Corp., Mr. Stumpf said.

Shares should hit $68 within the next 12 months, he said.

Despite the assessment, included in a report full of superlatives, Commerce shares were hammered.

Banks suffered once again as short-term investors said "it's time to lock in my profits and rotate out of the group into another," said Charles M. Vincent, a banking analyst with PNC Asset Management who has been following the stock market for three decades.

Banks and broad markets had jumped as a group the day before, when the first handful of second-quarter earnings reports, including those by financial institutions, met or exceeded analysts' expectations. "What you're seeing is a settling down to reality following a bit of euphoria," Mr. Vincent said.

Indeed, the banks that did report, while showing income gains, also experienced some margin pressure, he said. And there is no guarantee that banks reporting in the coming days will post terrific second-quarter performances.

For the day, the Standard & Poor's bank index fell 1.20%, and the Dow Jones industrial average dipped 0.12%. The Nasdaq bank index shed 1.12%, and the S&P 500 was off 0.23%.

BankAmerica Corp. shed $2.75, to $96.5625; Bank of New York Corp. lost $1, to $65.50; and Wells Fargo & Co., up very strongly on Tuesday, dropped $11.4375, to $381.50.

At the same time, storm clouds may be gathering for any company that is not planning to grow nationally, one analyst said.

Shares of smaller banks "appear to be overvalued," said Richard X. Bove, a banking analyst with Raymond James Associates.

He feels that larger institutions-such as the new crop of megabanks-are more apt to sustain growth. Most other banks "are not positioned well enough" competitively, he said.

Subscribe Now

Access to authoritative analysis and perspective and our data-driven report series.

14-Day Free Trial

No credit card required. Complete access to articles, breaking news and industry data.