Pa. Bankers, Group Fight Credit Unions’ Bid for Large Fields

Register now

Bankers in Pennsylvania are urging state regulators to deny three credit unions’ applications for community charters, including an interstate bid that would involve one of the largest fields of membership ever granted.

The Pennsylvania Bankers Association, along with three banks, told an administrative law judge in mid-July that the fields of membership the credit unions are seeking would go beyond what state law allows. The bankers also argued that Freedom Credit Union in Philadelphia, TruMark Financial Credit Union in Trevose, and Corry Jamestown Credit Union are not capable of serving larger fields of membership.

The bankers’ challenge centers on the interpretation of a “well-defined, local or rural community” standard established by the National Credit Union Administration for community charters and adopted by most states.

In one of the first cases decided by the courts, the Virginia Supreme Court ruled this year that the state’s financial institutions regulator should judge whether the area a credit union is seeking to serve with a community charter qualifies as a well-defined, local or rural community. A state court in Missouri is expected to take up a similar issue later this year.

But the Pennsylvania matter is far from reaching the courts.

Paul Wenzel, a spokesman for the Pennsylvania Department, said that the administrative-hearing process is preliminary to the regulator’s decision on the applications.

A decision on the applications is expected this fall. Either side may appeal to a state court.

“We’ve never had a field-of-membership challenge before,” Mr. Wenzel said. “The current law, enacted in 2002, expanded field-of-membership rules, but the community charter allowance has always been in there.”

Of the three applications, Freedom’s is the most ambitious. The $263 million-asset credit union is seeking to convert to a community charter that would cover eight counties in Pennsylvania and New Jersey with a total population of more than 5 million.

TruMark, with $762 million of assets, has asked to serve 2.5 million people in 4 counties; the $12 million-asset Corry Jamestown wants to serve the 300,000 residents of Erie County.

Officials with the Pennsylvania Bankers Association could not comment, because the Banking Department has issued a gag order. The Pennsylvania Credit Union Association, which is providing legal assistance to the three applicants, also would not comment.

But an individual who attended the administrative hearings said the bankers argued that the large fields of membership — unprecedented for Pennsylvania-chartered credit unions — violate the parameters of the statute and its “well-defined, local or rural community” requirements.

The credit unions’ lawyers argued that regulators, not banks, must decide the matter, according to the source.

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.