Merger, labor expenses chip away at TD Bank's U.S. profits

Profits at Toronto-Dominion Bank's U.S. retail bank rose slightly during the fiscal third quarter despite higher expenses, some of which related to the company's proposed $13.4 billion acquisition of First Horizon Corp.

Net income from the Canadian bank's U.S. retail operation rose by 1%, or $5 million in U.S. dollars, compared with the same period last year, while noninterest expenses increased by $99 million.

During the fiscal third quarter, which runs from May to July, TD recorded $22 million in charges related to the acquisition and integration of Memphis, Tennessee-based First Horizon. TD also pointed to higher employee-related expenses and more spending on investments in the business as reasons for the uptick.

Toronto-Dominion Bank has until Nov. 27 to close its acquisition of First Horizon Corp. before the price increases by 65 cents per share.

TD Chief Executive Bharat Masrani said during a call with analysts Thursday that the Toronto-based bank still expects the First Horizon deal, which was announced in February, to close between November and January.

TD has until Nov. 27 to finish the acquisition before the price tag for First Horizon increases by 65 cents per share. If the transaction does not close by Feb. 27, 2023, either party has the right to terminate it, though that deadline can be extended by three months under certain conditions.

The TD-First Horizon merger has drawn opposition from Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., and various consumer advocacy groups. One issue flagged by the bank's critics is a $122 million settlement that TD agreed to pay in 2020 in connection with overdraft enrollment practices that regulators deemed deceptive.

TD has responded to the criticism by pointing to various changes it has made in its U.S. operations, including the launch of a program meant to increase homeownership opportunities in communities of color, the introduction of an overdraft-free bank account and other overdraft-related reforms.

The Center for Responsible Lending, the Woodstock Institute and other left-leaning groups argue that the $13.4 billion merger will harm low-income communities, reduce small-business lending and add to systemic risk.

August 24

At a recent public meeting hosted by the Federal Reserve and the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, some community groups said they support the TD-First Horizon deal. Other groups pushed regulators to hold off on approving the merger unless both banks agree to invest more in communities

Masrani said Thursday that TD executives are "pleased that our commitment to the communities that we serve was reflected in the support we heard for the transaction at the joint public meeting."

"We are excited about the benefits that our combined banks will deliver for all our stakeholders," Masrani said.

Between May and July, noninterest income from TD's U.S. retail bank fell by 10% from the same period last year to $504 million, which the company said primarily reflected a "higher valuation of certain investments" the previous year.

Across the entire company in the fiscal third quarter, TD reported a 9.4% decline in net income from the same period a year earlier. The company's results were hurt by a nearly $300 million increase in its provision for credit losses.

Update
This story has been updated to provide additional information about the rise in noninterest expenses and the decline in noninterest income at TD's U.S. retail bank.
August 26, 2022 2:15 PM EDT
For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Consumer banking Earnings M&A
MORE FROM AMERICAN BANKER