Comments of the Week: Is Financial Education Futile?; Onshoring vs. Offshoring

p17pldav021p6n1qbs1f9p1rqe1oia9.jpg
American Banker readers share their views on the most pressing banking topics of the week. As excerpted from the Comments sections of AmericanBanker.com articles.

(Image: Shutterstock)

p17pldav021aun1qak13ptip91tb96.jpg

On the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's rule-making process:

"One hopes that the personnel at the CFPB will be as diligent in revisiting and evaluating their handiwork as they are at constructing it."

Related Article: CFPB's Balancing Act: Protecting Consumers While Preserving Credit Access

(Image: Bloomberg News)

p17pldav021k6n4fhedh1e8uniee.jpg

On the Brown-Vitter 'Too Big to Fail' bill:

"Their objective is admirable. However, they have chosen the wrong tool to bring it about. It's not about the capital; it's about the subsidy."

Related Article: Why the Brown-Vitter Bill Matters - Even if It Doesn't Pass

p17pldav021doennt12coou2f758.jpg

On a call to give existing reforms time before pushing the Brown-Vitter bill:

"Asking [us] to wait to see whether the post-Dodd-Frank Act and Basel III rule-making will produce the quality of supervision a healthy financial system needs is asking us to play the fool again."

Related Article: Why We Don't Need Brown-Vitter - Yet

(Image: Shutterstock)

p17pldav021no81rcakmo15d5u6fd.jpg

On banks teaching financial responsibility to consumers:

"It is incumbent on us all to elevate society's knowledge of financial matters. If for no other reason than to create a financially literate and informed electorate to vote on the increasingly technical matters of economics and finance that affects us all."

Related Article: Banks Have a Responsibility to Teach Financial Literacy

(Image: Shutterstock)

p17pldav021jqe19rt11j7m6pbtb.jpg

On banks teaching financial responsibility to consumers:

"Banks can provide all the financial knowledge in the world, but if the consumer does not try to seek it out and understand it, it's all for naught."

Related Article: Banks Have a Responsibility to Teach Financial Literacy

(Image: Shutterstock)

p17pldav0211ocege13ms6i71bm65.jpg

On Citi's call for banks to help build a nation of savers:

"Encouraging … our society to save more is a wonderful objective for Citi to pursue … I just don't believe it is as effective as teaching personal accountability and living within your means."

Related Article: Banks Have a Responsibility to Teach Financial Literacy

(Image: Shutterstock)

p17pldav0213f88r211cu1bhj1vd07.jpg

On regulators' crackdown on banks offering payday-like loans:

"The reason this news is interesting is that it provides one more demonstration of the futility of trying to help the poor by making lending to them more onerous."

Related Article: New Regs Could Wipe Out Bank Payday Loans

(Image: Shutterstock)

p17pldav01nsh11nt1j66vvp2443.jpg

On the ATM maker Diebold slashing jobs as part of an overhaul:

"It will be interesting to see whether the cuts include the least productive members of management, or are concentrated on the worker bees."

Related Article: Diebold to Slash Jobs, Cut Costs as Part of Overhaul

(Image: Shutterstock)

p17pldav021o0t13j538s1utc1u9k4.jpg

On Bitcoin's potential to disrupt payments:

"Bitcoin might be a means of payment, store of value and unit of account but I can't see how it's an ethical one."

Related Article: The Elephant in the Payments Room

p17pldav026lh9pp1a65o331hgpc.jpg

On the benefits of bringing bank jobs back to the U.S. from overseas:

"Note that the bulk of Silicon Valley firms have done very little offshoring. They kept things onshore and innovation is happening."

Related Article: Time to Bring Bank Staff Back Onshore

(Image: Shutterstock)

p17pldav021n8dln9egsq31738a.jpg

On the benefits of offshoring:

"It is no longer a cost arbitrage driving offshoring. It is the ability to scale with the right skills at the right time, flexible staffing options and the benefits of distributed operations around the globe."

Related Article: Time to Bring Bank Staff Back Onshore

(Image: Shutterstock)


MORE FROM AMERICAN BANKER
Load More