Wall Street nemesis to join House panel's Deutsche Bank probe
The House Financial Services Committee is hiring a Senate lawyer with deep experience conducting complex investigations to help run its upcoming probe of Deutsche Bank AG, according to people briefed on the matter.
Bob Roach, who is expected to join the House committee’s staff under new Chairwoman Maxine Waters later this month, has spent more than two decades digging into dubious banking practices from his former perch with the Senate’s Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations. Few prominent Wall Street firms have been left untouched by his work.
Roach’s past investigations for the Senate panel constitute a rogues’ gallery of financial misconduct spanning several eras. They have focused on Goldman Sachs Group Inc.’s “big short’’ against the housing market prior to the financial crisis; Credit Suisse Group AG’s efforts to help U.S. citizens evade taxes; HSBC Holdings PLC’s shoddy oversight of money laundering by drug cartels; and the roles played by Citigroup Inc. and JPMorgan Chase & Co. in helping Enron Corp. maintain a facade of profitability before its collapse.
The Financial Services committee plans to examine allegations that Deutsche Bank helped launder money on behalf of Russian customers and to probe the bank’s business dealings with President Donald Trump and his family. Trump has some $340 million in loans from the German lender, according to his most recent financial disclosures.
Roach “loves digging up facts,” said former Sen. Carl Levin, a Michigan Democrat who ran the investigations subcommittee and is now teaching about oversight as chair of the Levin Center at Wayne State University’s law school. “He is a straight-shooter, he is thorough and he’s fair.”
Levin and former colleagues say Roach won’t take a partisan approach. “He keeps a pretty level playing field,” said Gary Brown, a Republican lawyer who worked with him on the Senate subcommittee and is a partner at the Nelson Mullins Riley & Scarborough law firm in Nashville. “In a lot of these investigations, it is not Democrat versus Republican, it is right versus wrong.”
The hiring, said attorneys and others who’ve dealt with Roach, is a signal that the committee’s oversight of Deutsche Bank — one of the few banks that extended loans to Trump in recent years — won’t be a political rush job. Instead, Roach is known for conducting thorough reviews of thousands of documents, interviewing lots of witnesses and writing lengthy reports that often lead to new legislation and other reforms.
Roach declined to comment. A spokesman for Deutsche Bank declined to comment. A spokesman for the Financial Services panel declined to comment on Roach’s hiring. With regard to the committee’s work, the spokesman pointed to a previous joint statement in which Waters and House Intelligence Committee Chairman Adam Schiff said they’d work together on their probes: “The House Financial Services and Intelligence Committees are engaged in productive discussions with Deutsche Bank, and look forward to continued cooperation.”
Roach will arrive as the Financial Services panel is beginning to organize its investigation, the people said. He has most recently worked for the minority staff of the Senate Banking Committee, where he has been reviewing Wall Street’s compliance with government settlements.
The Intelligence panel is examining alleged money laundering involving Russia and the Trump Organization, the president’s former business that is now run by his sons, Donald Jr. and Eric. That committee is also making several hires, including people with backgrounds in finance and forensic accounting, according to three officials familiar with the matter.
Schiff of California this week said his committee will probe whether foreign governments or individuals have had improper leverage over the president or his business interests. Schiff didn’t mention Deutsche Bank by name. But a report that Democrats on the Intelligence committee wrote last year — before they gained a majority in the House — did. It said:
“We must also seek to determine: Did the Russian government, through business figures close to the Kremlin, seek to court Donald Trump and launder funds through the Trump Organization; and did candidate Trump’s financial exposure via Deutsche Bank or other private loans constitute a point of leverage that Russia may have exploited and may still be using?”
Trump, meanwhile, said in a Twitter message Thursday that the Democrats “and their committees are going ‘nuts’ ” and labeled the planned investigations “a continuation of Witch Hunt!”
People familiar with the Financial Services committee said it’s also looking for someone with a background in investigative reporting to help write reports. The panel’s plans for Deutsche Bank — and other issues — are likely to emerge soon, they said.
Waters began to pay particular attention to Deutsche Bank in 2017, asking the lender to provide detailed information about its relationships with Trump and his family. Because the committee was controlled by Republicans, who did not share her interest in examining the bank’s loans to Trump, Waters’ efforts went nowhere.
Now, with the power to issue subpoenas, the California Democrat can demand detailed client information from Deutsche Bank.
Waters has also looked at Deutsche Bank’s role in helping wealthy Russians move more than $12 billion worth of rubles into the western financial system through a practice known as “mirror trading.” The Federal Reserve, the U.K. Financial Conduct Authority and New York’s Department of Financial Services have all fined Deutsche Bank for its lax oversight of the Russian money transfers.
The Department of Justice conducted its own investigation into the scandal and appeared to be close to sanctioning the bank in the last months of 2016. Following Trump’s election and the installation of new leadership at the agency, the investigation into mirror trading appeared to stall. Waters is likely to renew her request to the Justice Department for an update on it.
Roach, 66, cemented his reputation as a Wall Street nemesis during his tenure on the Senate investigations subcommittee. Along with the subcommittee’s chief counsel, Elise Bean, Roach conducted deep dives on issues like abusive tax shelters, money laundering and the financial firms that helped prop up Enron.
The panel’s look at the origins of the financial crisis captivated both Washington and Wall Street during a 2010 hearing where Levin grilled Lloyd Blankfein, then Goldman’s chief executive officer, about the firm’s decision to bet against the housing market even as it sold mortgage securities that the bank internally referred to as “crap.’’
“Your people think it’s a piece of crap and go out and sell it,” Levin said as he harangued Blankfein.
Though Goldman garnered much of the public attention in that investigation, Deutsche Bank was also highlighted by the subcommittee for peddling collateralized debt obligations that its own traders believed were likely to lose value.
Deutsche was also singled out in an investigation Roach handled involving hedge funds’ use of complex financial products to avoid taxes.
The subcommittee’s 2014 report accused Deutsche Bank and Barclays Plc of marketing certain types of options to hedge funds that allowed investors to improperly reduce their tax burdens. Renaissance Technologies, one firm that bought the options from the banks, avoided more than $6 billion in taxes over 14 years, the report concluded.