Bank-managed mutual funds slightly lagged behind their nonbank counterparts during the second quarter, a period that saw a rally in both the stock and taxable bond markets.

The strong returns in domestic stocks and bonds, combined with a recovery in international equity markets, gave an edge to nonbank funds, which generally have a more aggressive exposure to these markets than their more conservative bank counterparts.

During the period, nonbank stock funds posted average returns of 7.91%, edging out bank funds by a tenth of a percentage point, according to CDA/Wiesenberger, a Rockville, Md., fund tracking fund.

The bank-managed stock funds with the strongest performance during the quarter were First Bank System's First American Technology, U.S. Trust Corp.'s UST Master-Emerging Americas, and Wells Fargo's Overland Express Strategic. The funds were up 22.8%, 19.97%, and 17.57%, respectively.

The nonbank funds also outperformed their bank rivals in taxable bond and mixed funds, with average returns of 5.1% and 7.08%, respectively, compared with 4.84% and 6.86% for the bank funds.

Huntington Bancshares' Monitor Mortgage Securities was the top- performing taxable bond fund during the period, with a 10.89% return, while Dreyfus Asset Allocation-Total Return took top honors in the mixed category, gaining 9.64% .

The only category during the quarter in which banks showed supremacy was tax-exempt funds, though the advantage was little consolation given the overall weakness of a category racked by fallout from the Orange County debacle and investor concerns about a federal flat-tax proposal that would endanger the attraction of tax-free bonds.

The average return for bank-managed munis was a paltry 2.11% for the period, compared with nonbank's 1.88%. UST Master-Tax Exempt Intermediate led the pack of bank-managed muni funds.

While nonbank funds had the edge in the quarter, bank fund managers and their customers had little to complain about.

For one, nonbank funds registered only a slight edge in performance. And the bank funds, benefiting from buoyant domestic markets, registered stronger returns in the stock and taxable bond categories than they did during the first quarter, a period in which they outperformed the nonbanks.

"It's hard to make a case that the banks did worse than the nonbanks during the quarter," said Jon Teall, a research analyst with Lipper Analytical Services, a Summit, N.J., fund tracking firm. "The numbers are awfully close."

The second quarter was particularly kind to technology mutual funds, so it's no surprise that the top-performing bank-managed equity fund - First American Technology - was in that category.

The 18-month-old fund, one of the newest offerings of the 24- fund First American family, is managed by First Asset Management, the investment arm of Minneapolis-based First Bank System. The fund, which has $15 million in assets, was up a whopping 22.8% during the quarter and 29.38% for the first six months of the year.

These stellar results were achieved through investments from small-cap semiconductor companies to blue chips such as Hewlett-Packard.

The technology fund is considered among the most aggressive of First American's offerings, said John Murphy, the chief investment officer of First Asset Management.

Subscribe Now

Access to authoritative analysis and perspective and our data-driven report series.

14-Day Free Trial

No credit card required. Complete access to articles, breaking news and industry data.