BankThink

What are stablecoins good for, other than enabling speculation?

BankThink re: stablecoins more hype than help
With no clear use case other than enabling speculation in volatile cryptocurrencies, stablecoins have turned out to be more hype than help for most people, writes Neeraj Baid, founder and CEO of Atlantic Money.
Krakenimages.com - stock.adobe.com

The cryptocurrency world is changing rapidly as major exchanges like Binance and Tether address scandals, while established companies like PayPal or even the first big banks like the Société Générale nonchalantly unveil stablecoins. These competing developments raise important questions about the industry's resilience and goals. 

As global brands dip their toes in the waters, the ongoing drama surrounding longtime power players continues to shape public perceptions. It prompts a re-examination of how well the sector fulfills its promises of independence, security and mass adoption.

In the midst of these controversies, regulatory bodies like the Financial Conduct Authority and the European Banking Authority strive to bring order to an inherently turbulent landscape. Yet, the overarching question persists: Does cryptocurrency possess a genuine use case beyond its role as a speculative investment?

Stablecoins are currently said to be the closest to this change. These are cryptocurrencies whose value is pegged to a generally stable fiat currency, for example, the U.S. Dollar, and are therefore hardly subject to any fluctuations.

While stablecoins do find utility as a base currency for navigating between volatile cryptocurrencies, their broader application as a fiat money alternative remains elusive. In a landscape where traditional payment solutions offer safety, affordability and widely available systems, businesses and consumers find no compelling reason to embrace stablecoins. Until this missing use case is convincingly addressed, stablecoins risk relegation to the domain of speculative asset-enablers rather than evolving into essential tools for everyday financial transactions.

Projects are underway at a number of payment firms including PayPal, Circle and Ripple. Location and regulation will also play a big role in what the market looks like in the next year.

December 29
Allaire-Jeremy-Circle

Conversely, the existing fiat money system, with its familiarity and stability, holds clear advantages. Fiat currencies provide a resilient foundation for global economic transactions, ensuring seamless interactions. Fiat money commands the trust and confidence of consumers, a sentiment built over generations of dependable use.

However, advocates for stablecoins often tout their potential to serve as a financial lifeline for the unbanked and underbanked in regions lacking traditional banking infrastructure. Indeed, people in volatile currency regions use stablecoins to hedge against the common surprises of ups and downs.

Despite that, practical challenges in converting cryptocurrencies into cash, particularly in areas where daily sustenance hinges on physical money exchange, remain a significant hurdle to day-to-day adoption. The ability to convert stablecoins into local currency stands as a crucial yet absent link, hindering individuals from realizing the transformative potential. Even more crucially, governments — like Argentina, India or China to name a few — actively oppose large-scale adoption of cryptocurrencies, as such a transition would challenge their grip on their nation's monetary policy. 

Until stablecoins effectively address these challenges and seamlessly integrate into local economies, their transformative promise remains unrealized. No matter how virtuous the vision, it shatters against the reality of practical obstacles.

In conclusion, while regulatory progress is positive, it alone is not the cure for crypto's everyday use case. The industry must confront challenges in achieving seamless transitions, widespread adoption and enhanced user security. Until then, the stability, familiarity and universal acceptance of the existing fiat money system will continue to outshine the unfulfilled promises of the crypto realm.

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Cryptocurrency Regulation and compliance
MORE FROM AMERICAN BANKER