James Dimon, JPMorgan Chase CEO
Total compensation: $23.1M
Change from 2010: 11%
Company ROAA: 0.8%
Total return on company stock: -20%
GMI compensation risk rating: Very high concern Incentive awards determined at discretion of board rather than by performance benchmarks
(Image: Bloomberg News; Data for 2011)
Kenneth Chenault, Amex CEO
Total compensation: $23M
Change from 2010: 37%
Company ROAA: 3.3%
Total return on company stock: 12%
GMI compensation risk rating: Very high concern Generous perquisites, including $200,000 for Chenault's use of company aircraft
(Image: Bloomberg News; Data for 2011)
John Stumpf, Wells Fargo CEO
Total compensation: $19.8M
Change from 2010: 5%
Company ROAA: 1.2%
Total return on company stock: -10%
GMI compensation risk rating: High concern Long-term performance awards "pay out even if the company underperforms all of its peers but one"
(Image: Bloomberg News; Data for 2011)
Richard Fairbank, Capital One CEO
Total compensation: $18.7M
Change from 2010: 26%
Company ROAA: 1.5%
Total return on company stock: 0%
GMI compensation risk rating: High concern Pay insufficiently tied to performance; Fairbank could receive $50 million in cash and benefits from change in control
(Data for 2011)
James Rohr, PNC CEO
Total compensation: $16.6M
Change from 2010: 0%
Company ROAA: 1.1%
Total return on company stock: -3%
GMI compensation risk rating: Moderate concern Rohr's pay is more than three times the median for other top executives, raising "concerns about internal pay equity"
(Image: Bloomberg News; Data for 2011)
Joseph Hooley, State Street CEO
Total compensation: $16.2M
Change from 2010: 25%
Company ROAA: 1.0%
Total return on company stock: -11%
GMI compensation risk rating: High concern One type of incentive compensation tied to a measure of operating income alone - "a mix of performance metrics is more appropriate"
(Data for 2011)
Vikram Pandit, Citi CEO
Total compensation: $14.9M
Change from 2010: $1 in 2010
Company ROAA: 0.6%
Total return on company stock: -44%
GMI compensation risk rating: High concern 2011 "mega grant" of 500,000 options to Pandit vest over time alone, but prohibition on golden parachutes
(Image: Bloomberg News; Data for 2011)
Frederick Waddell, Northern Trust CEO
Total compensation: $14.3M
Change from 2010: 12%
Company ROAA: 0.7%
Total return on company stock: -27%
GMI compensation risk rating: Moderate concern Annual cash incentives "not tied to any specific formula" - explicit performance-based criteria are better
(Image: Bloomberg News; Data for 2011)