p18qq6di218spab6sjapt15bt6.jpg
OmniAmerican (OABC) had a good problem earlier this year: competing offers from eager buyers. The Texas bank, which "accepted a slightly smaller price" from Southside Bancshares (SBSI), explained its reasoning in a regulatory filing. Here are the highlights.

(Image: Thinkstock)

p18qq6kdvsh2t1n8ut6e18dk16958.jpg

Dividend Yield

Southside currently has a 2.7% dividend yield that was "significantly" higher than the payout of the other unnamed suitor. That should benefit OmniAmerican's smaller investors, who rely heavily on dividends.

(Image: Thinkstock)

p18qq6r8o1qv7vbk1ko91nu3o0qa.jpg

Board Representation

OmniAmerican is getting two board seats at Southside once the deal is completed, which gives it a voice at the company. The filing never mentions a similar offer from the other bank.

(Image: Thinkstock)

p18qq8ke4rdtagg0m7512sd51mk.jpg

Potential for Stock Appreciation

Directors at OmniAmerican took into consideration that Southside had a lower price-to-earnings ratio than the other suitor. In theory, that could mean a higher stock price as Southside's valuation aligns with its earnings power.

(Image: Thinkstock)

p18qq6vv0j1dl614el11t1uob1kfrc.jpg

Stock Performance

The filing notes that Southside has enjoyed strong, consistent stock performance in recent years. OmniAmerican's board was concerned about the "historical volatility" of the other suitor's stock.

(Image: Thinkstock)

p18qq71umnod11b5g18a812ue13r6e.jpg

Stock Dividends

Southside has a history of giving shareholders an annual 5% stock dividend, which was appealing to OmniAmerican’s board.

(Image: Thinkstock)

p18qq748bejt61cv2d1n10r0tfeg.jpg

Preferable Loan Mix

OmniAmerican compared the loan portfolios of its suitors. They liked the fact that Southside has a smaller concentration of commercial real estate loans compared to the other bank.

(Image: Thinkstock)

p18qq8pes319fbl4hs1k1q81mcgm.jpg

Regulatory Considerations

OmniAmerican's board said it believes Southside will have an easier time getting the deal approved than the other suitor. The filing also pointed to Southside's excellent CRA rating.

(Image: Thinkstock)

p18qq7dr091ve5htourq1cpp1mg5i.jpg

Culture and Strategy

OmniAmerican's board liked Southside's commitment to retail banking, compared to a "smaller retail presence" at the other bank. OmniAmerican and Southside also seemed to click culturally, the filing added.

(Image: Thinkstock)

MORE FROM AMERICAN BANKER