p19i8bqvg2k6c1m1t1bjf1jsskri6.jpg
Enactment of the Durbin amendment in the Dodd-Frank Act was just the start of a fight over implementing debit interchange rules. Retailers ultimately lost their legal effort to toughen the Federal Reserve's swipe fee cap, but they are now arguing that issuers offering Apple Pay service are skirting the Fed's regulation. Here's a look back at how the battle has played out.

Image: iStock
p19i8bqvh011k85b41t381g7vc9t7.jpg

Limits on Debit Swipe Fees Become Law

As lawmakers debated the 2010 regulatory overhaul later known as the Dodd-Frank Act, Sen. Richard Durbin, D-Ill., offered an amendment — unrelated to the financial crisis — to require Federal Reserve Board rules restricting debit swipe fees. Under the law, debit interchange fees had to be "reasonable and proportional" with the cost of processing a payment, though the amendment exempted banks with less than $10 billion in assets. The provision also required issuers to ensure payments could be routed through at least two unaffiliated networks.

Image: Bloomberg News
p19i8bqvh72qf10ru1tq01odbgvd8.jpg

Fed Issues New Interchange Fee Cap

After first proposing a lower fee limit, the Fed's 2011 final rule ultimately capped debit interchange fees at 24 cents per transaction. To comply with the dual routing requirement, the Fed said banks could issue debit cards that carry one PIN debit network and one signature debit networks, as long as the two networks were unaffiliated.
p19i8bqvhbevcmgolmbb3h5jf9.jpg

Judge Calls Fed Rule 'Utterly Indefensible'

Despite the new regulation, merchants and Durbin himself called the Fed's rule inadequate, saying the central bank set the cap too high. After retailers sued the Fed, they won agreement in a 2013 ruling from U.S. District Judge Richard Leon, who overturned both the fee limit and the dual routing rules. "In short, the … [Fed's] interpretation is utterly indefensible," Leon said in his strongly worded decision.

Image: Thinkstock
p19i8bqvhj1pd19uv7eavb818afc.jpg

Appeals Court Sides with Fed

Banks scored a huge victory when a three-judge panel for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia overturned Leon's ruling, thereby cementing the Fed's rule. The appeals court appeared sympathetic to the Fed's position during oral arguments. After retailers argued the law required the Fed to rely only on processor costs specified in Dodd-Frank when setting the cap, Judge Harry Edwards said, "None of us buy that."
p19i8bqvhi2t46iq1sevdbv1u8sb.jpg

Legal Battle Ends at Steps of Supreme Court

The legal fight over the Durbin amendment ceased as retailers' lost their bid to argue their case before the Supreme Court. The high court's denial of the merchants' petition for a hearing appeared to signal the matter would be resolved once and for all.

Image: iStock
p19i8bqvhkkn02511kfq1nhoj21d.jpg

Merchants Allege Compliance Issues with Apple Pay

Retailers and payments industry observers say the introduction of Apple Pay and other contactless services run afoul of the Durbin amendment's dual routing provisions by directing debit transactions by default through the Visa and MasterCard signature networks, hiding access to the alternative PIN debit networks.

Image: Bloomberg News
MORE FROM AMERICAN BANKER