p19adv8kmj1dsmdpakia1jo3v8e6.jpg
We revisit some of the best comments readers posted in 2014. Comments are excerpted from reader response sections of AmericanBanker.com and BankThink.com articles, except where noted.

Image: Fotolia
p199v4a22i42k1ga7e6k1kcp1qeg7.jpg

On how banks should approach their assessments of customers' creditworthiness:

"Nothing can improve upon good underwriting. I watched FICO grow in use and cause a drug-like reliance in lenders. Big data has some value but we need other old school techniques to make this work for people that don't have big data to access."

Related Article: Shifting the Debate on Small-Dollar Credit

Image: iStock
p199v4a22k1id1jhh1dp98ln6r88.jpg

On whether economies of scale exist in the banking industry:

"When our processes are so complex that we have checkers checking checkers, and then G-man checkers checking the checkers, that don't scale."

Related Article: Why Scale Is Overrated in Banking, in Two Charts

Image: Fotolia
p199v4a22l12rn1o5qalt1mq612rg9.jpg

On the intended purpose of the Federal Reserve's emergency powers:

"The Fed discount window and other lending facilities are not meant to keep bad banks afloat any more than a bartender is meant to keep serving drinks to a drunk."

Related Article: Lawmakers Push Fed to Rein In Emergency Powers

Image: Fotolia
p199v4a22m8kj1ckcloga5ct9a.jpg

On how smartphones are changing Americans' day-to-day behaviors:

"Technology advances with smartphones have only increased consumers' dependence on them for daily activities. My twenty-something-year-old kids are so tied to their phones they would use them to heat up their macaroni and cheese if it was a feature."

Related Article: Why the New York Times Is Wrong About Apple Pay

Image: Fotolia
p199v7039v1gcr1ooi119ettudh06.jpg

On alternatives to the complex Volcker Rule:

"A simpler and less costly idea is to reinstitute the Glass-Steagall Act. Put the wall in place and create stable utility businesses. There is too much money at play now; the situation is much like pro sports. Teams and the league try to enforce the [performance-enhancing drug] rules and conduct, but really don't want to, and end up looking the other way when possible. It's human nature. Make the solution simple and take the guessing out of the equation."

Related Article: Why Volcker Rule Compliance Is a Fool's Errand

Image: Bloomberg News
p199v4a22p1b2515lu61lid1lcfc.jpg

On the reasons for the dearth of female chief executives in the banking industry:

"While women comprise over 50% of the financial industry, only 2% of bank CEOs are female. The question isn't whether women are entitled to ascend to these positions but rather why aren't they ascending? … I cannot believe … that the lack of brains and ability is preventing women from promotions into a bank's C-suite. Their limited representation strongly implies that there are barriers for women to achieve senior-level positions." (Pictured: KeyCorp CEO Beth Mooney)

Related Article: Fix the Female Executive Shortage with Data, Dialogue, and Janet Yellen

Image: Bloomberg News
p199v4a22q1jvejgp1uk1m8q1gj8d.jpg

On a banker's proposal for a more-secure Internet payment system that requires identification of all users:

"Banks are hosed, but are still enormously profitable and they might be able to roll out chip-and-PIN in the USA fast enough that these breaches such as those at Target become a memory. They have such a fetish for 'know your customer.' Ugh." (Via Reddit.)

Related Article: Legacy Bank Payment Systems and the Internet: A Toxic Cocktail

Image: iStock
p199v4a22r1ag1c751kl019qj19hce.jpg

On JPMorgan Chase refusing to process payments for a condom company due to reputational risk:

"As if JPMorgan Chase … has such a sterling reputation, that it would be besmirched by processing payments for a distributor of female condoms."

Related Article: JPMorgan, Condoms and the Problem of Reputational Risk

Image: Bloomberg News
p199v4a22s185k1vk817dn1iie1f77f.jpg

On blaming Operation Choke Point for JPMorgan's severing ties with a condom seller:

"As if it's the regulators' fault that financial institutions heard about banning scam artists and decided to ban condom shops instead." (via Naked Capitalism)

Related Article: JPMorgan, Condoms and the Problem of Reputational Risk

Image: Fotolia
p19ab11iuf1qk81vhm1l9rrpr19g6.jpg

On the argument that taxpayers remain on the hook for bank failures:

"Another basic principle of economic efficiency … is to try to internalize all the real costs of economic activity. Unfortunately customers, shareholders and executives are easily able to externalize much of the real costs of their activity when they have the moral hazard of deposit insurance and government bailouts. Now if we could eliminate ["too big to fail"] this might be different. But if one thinks this will happen in today's environment then let's put Santa in charge of the Fed."

Related Article: Let Customers — Not Regulators — Decide the Right

p199v4a22t92g9nr1cssn7q1gmdg.jpg

On a commenter's flippant suggestion to put Santa Claus in charge of the Fed:

p199v4a22u2vq5gbqk1rr61p5oh.jpg

On lavish spending by executives at CertusBank:

"Can a bank fail twice?"

Related Article: Certus Dream Team Gets Its Wake-Up Call

p199v4a230617vnd87a10gecjri.jpg

On banks' efforts to gather new client data in order to personalize customer service:

"It's been my experience that banks have a lot more information about their customers than they know. Often, that detail is hoarded, in the great bank silo tradition, knowingly or unknowingly. I can't help but wonder how much of the 'new' collection is redundant effort."

Related Article: Banks Beef Up Data-Gathering in Bid to Personalize Service

Image: Fotolia
p199v4a231oeu1d9gmeq1d0u1sebj.jpg

On the news that Thomas O'Brien, the new president and CEO of Sun Bancorp, planned to cut 242 jobs and close the bank's retail mortgage, health care and asset-based lending businesses:

"I want a Tom O'Brien action figure doll for Christmas!"

Related Article: Sun Bancorp Cutting 40% of Work Force, Exiting Businesses

Image: Fotolia
MORE FROM AMERICAN BANKER