AmEx, Discover Best at Customer Satisfaction; Big Banks Falter

ab081811satisfy.jpg

What's the secret to American Express Co.'s customer satisfaction success?

The New York credit card company once again beat out its top competitors in J.D. Power's annual ranking of U.S. credit card customer satisfaction, released on Thursday.

It was hardly a surprising victory — American Express has won the top spot in the annual ranking every year since J.D. Power started it in 2007. This year the company earned a score of 786 on a 1,000 point scale, beating the industry average of 731 (see graphic).

American Express, which lends mostly to the wealthy, has long relied on its vaunted customer service and expansive rewards programs to attract business and buzz. Since the worst of the financial crisis forced it to retreat from broader consumer lending, the company is also hoping its forays into online and mobile payments will gain it more fans among the young and tech-savvy.

J.D. Power said in a press release that American Express's customer satisfaction score this year got a special boost from the company's "benefits and services, credit card terms and rewards factors."

Some of the other top performers were less obvious. Discover Financial Services appears to be the most underrated credit card service provider; it nearly matched American Express with a score of 779. According to J.D. Power, the Riverwoods, Ill., card company is particularly good at interacting with customers.

"Discover has narrowed the gap with American Express," says Michael Beird, director of banking services at J.D. Power.

Both companies "know the needs of their customer base. ... Their communications are ongoing, they utilize multiple channels, their customers have a higher level of understanding of the programs they're in," Beird says.

Barclaycard was another surprising outperformer, scoring slightly better than the average with 739. The U.S. credit card arm of Barclays is not the most prominent consumer brand and usually stays in the shadow of a retail or affinity partners like the National Football League.

The biggest U.S. banks did not fare as well. JPMorgan Chase & Co was slightly above the average, and Wells Fargo & Co. was slightly below it. But the long-suffering Citigroup Inc. and Bank of America Corp. are still struggling to convince their customers that their service levels have improved after the financial crisis.

Beird attributed some of those lower scores to negative publicity about the banks that barely survived the crisis, adding that Citigroup "saw a notable lift in its brand image" over the past year. (Vikram Pandit is probably sending daily flowers to Brian Moynihan for taking over the bad headlines these days.)

And the worst performer probably won't be on this list next year. HSBC, which has long specialized in lending to riskier U.S. borrowers and to retail partners' customers, came in at the bottom of the list with a 689 score.

Let's see if Capital One Financial Corp. — which is paying HSBC a $2.6 billion premium for a $30 billion U.S. card portfolio — can bring that customer satisfaction up in time for next year's survey.

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Consumer banking
MORE FROM AMERICAN BANKER