Fed proposal calls for higher threshold for BSA/AML citation

Michael Barr
Federal Reserve Gov. Michael Barr criticized a proposed rule raising the standards for supervisors to bring enforcement actions against banks for anti-money laundering violations.
Bloomberg News
  • Key insight: The Federal Reserve proposal would set a higher threshold for supervisors looking to cite banks for their Bank Secrecy Act/anti-money laundering deficiencies. Failures must be "significant or systemic" for an enforcement action to be taken.
  • Expert quote: "I am concerned that the 'significant or systemic' standard may have unknown effects on the Board's ability to effectively substantiate that a supervised institution establishes and maintains AML and [Countering the Finance of Terrorism] programs in compliance with the rule. I believe it is critical that the Federal Reserve maintain a strong AML/CFT supervisory program." — Federal Reserve Gov. Michael Barr
  • Forward Look: The proposal aligns with the Fed's increased focus on material financial risks under Vice Chair for Supervision Michelle Bowman. 

The Federal Reserve Board is considering changes to its anti-money laundering policy that would see banks tailor their compliance around risks. It also pledged to shift its enforcement from "isolated" deficiencies by banks to "systemic" shortcomings.

Processing Content

In a proposal issued for public comment on Tuesday afternoon, the Fed outlined a host of changes intended to modernize its Bank Secrecy Act/anti-money laundering compliance standards and synchronize them with equivalent frameworks from other financial regulators as well as the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, also known as Fincen.

The Fed Board of Governors voted 6-1 to issue the proposal.

Under the proposed framework, the Fed would direct banks to take a "risk-based" approach to their compliance programs, one that dedicates more resources to higher-risk customers and activities.

The proposal also calls for a higher standard for BSA/AML-related enforcement actions. It notes that banks can only be cited for "significant or systemic failures" in implementing their compliance programs, rather than "isolated, technical, or immaterial" issues.

The proposal notes that the changed standard for supervisory enforcement will not apply to implementation deficiencies, but rather will only impact how banks are treated once they have a program in place.

"The proposed rule would not limit enforcement or supervisory actions for failures to establish an AML/[countering the financing of terrorism] program," the proposal reads. "However, once a Board-supervised bank has properly established an AML/CFT program, the proposed rule would raise the threshold for significant supervisory or enforcement actions based solely on implementation deficiencies." 

The move aligns with the broader effort under Fed Vice Chair for Supervision Michelle Bowman to focus the central bank's supervisory work on risks that are material, quantifiable and tied to financial performance. 

Fed Gov. Michael Barr was the sole dissenting vote on the proposal. In a statement, he said he could not support the proposal because it introduced a "new, undefined standard" for issuing citations — known as matters requiring attention — or formal enforcement actions. 

"I am concerned that the 'significant or systemic' standard may have unknown effects on the Board's ability to effectively substantiate that a supervised institution establishes and maintains AML and CFT programs in compliance with the rule," Barr said. "I believe it is critical that the Federal Reserve maintain a strong AML/CFT supervisory program."

Barr served as vice chair of supervision directly before Bowman took the reins last year. He was appointed by then-President Joe Biden in the spring of 2022 and stepped down in the face of pressure from President Donald Trump at the end of February 2025. He has been a consistent opponent to supervisory and regulatory reforms implemented under Bowman. 

The proposal will be open to public comment for 60 days.


For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
AML Risk Compliance Risk Regulation and compliance
MORE FROM AMERICAN BANKER
Load More